Reference points are fundamental to most behavioral decision-making. Prior scholarship has shown how reference points, e.g. aspiration levels, are not stable nor ever-present. We argue that these findings can be explained through reference point formation, the process of how reference points come into existence. From a cognitive-behavioral perspective, reference point formation needs to be understood through information processing. In this study, we measure changes in the distribution of attention, which are indicative of whether there are changes in decision-makers’ cognitive mechanisms. Using an innovative two-stage methodology, we first link how a specific shock in the information environment alters decision-makers’ allocation of attention across different loci. Second, we find that the relationship between reference points and risk-taking is dependent on whether there occurred a shift in the distribution of attention. Our main contribution is, through establishing the significance of reference point formation, that the existence of reference points is dependent on preceding cognitive processes. Another contribution is methodological, as our empirical approach and novel measurement techniques allow for a joint investigation of cognitive processes and reference dependence.